Guest Blogger - Angie with teachagiftedkid.com Although this wonderful teacher teaches out of Louisiana, her insights into GT education can be translated to our needs as well.

I believe that we should be doing more to inform and support the parents of our newly identified students. I came to this realization during a recent encounter at, of all places, a car repair shop. I was passing the time waiting for my car to get serviced by playing a game on my iPad when a mother and her two elementary aged daughters walked in. It didn’t take long for the oldest girl to casually take a peek at my game. I noted that she was intensely interested in her surroundings and, like most children, she was seeking out mental stimulation in a boring place. I mentioned to the mom that I was a teacher and shared one of the interactive books that I had downloaded onto my iPad. Soon, mom and I were in a discussion where she shared that her little girl had been recently identified as a gifted second grader.

What happened next formed the inspiration for this post. Within minutes of telling the mother that I was a teacher of the gifted, the questions came pouring out. “My second grader was just identified at the end of last school year, what should I be doing now?” “Should I have known she was gifted before she was identified?” “Was there something that I wrote that might have hindered or helped my child during the process because I felt like I was being tested, too.”

These questions indicated to me that this parent 1) was probably not given any information other than her child’s test scores 2) doubted her own parenting skills since she didn’t know that her child was gifted before testing 3) and she wasn’t informed of her role in the identification process. I believe that all these questions symbolize the lack of information and support that should have been provided by the school staff or private testing service to the parent before, during and after the identification process. This interaction led me to reflect on what I do to inform and support the parent of a newly identified gifted child.

In the qualification letter that I send home to the parent I include links to my district’s resources and my own online website. This assumes that the parent has time to look at these resources. I am hoping that they do because there is an incredible amount of resources online which was not available 20 years ago when my own children were identified. I also ask the parents to tap into my News Flashes to keep abreast of the next parent support group meeting or seminar offered in the area. I had four successful parent support group meetings last year and a local college hosted a parent’s seminar partnering with TxGifted. We discussed things like perfectionism, making friends, academic achievement (or lack of academic achievement) and opportunities outside of school hours. I hope to continue offer these discussions again this coming year. But is this enough?

I tried to assure the mom at the car repair shop that she may not have known that her daughter was gifted before she was identified. Parents know their child very well but may not know how they compare intellectually to other children. It’s likely they see some characteristics about their child that are different but ‘chalk it up’ to individual preferences, not giftedness. I look back at my own experiences with my son and daughter and I recall some characteristics that might have indicated giftedness. Maybe I will spot them in my grandchildren but I’m guessing that I won’t. Many times, it’s not until the child is placed in an environment such as a classroom where their characteristics and behaviors become evident. This is where the professional educator comes in. We have to rely on testing and observations by a professional who is trained to identify the gifted learner to confirm that we are dealing with a gifted learner.

This brings me back to the setting that inspired this piece. The guys who service my car are professionals who are trained to determine whether my car is functioning at its peak performance. I have to trust that they are qualified to do their job and that they are reliably informing me what needs to be done to meet this goal. It’s the same with the job of the professional educator. Educators are professionally trained to determine and should be meeting the needs of each child whether they be special needs, on-level or above level.

The mom at the service station was concerned that something she wrote about her child during the identification process could have hindered her child from getting “accepted into the gifted program.” She felt like she was the one being tested. I first heard a similar comment during one of the parent support group meetings that I held last school year. I remember being asked to write about my children during their identification process over 20 years ago. I was just happy to let someone else know all about the wonderful things my children were doing at home. What parent wouldn’t want to do this? I didn’t even think about how it affected his or her acceptance into a program. I know that today’s parents need and want more information so they can “do” the right thing for their child.

I decided to ask one of my parents what she needed but was not provided during those first few weeks of finding out that her child had been identified as a gifted learner. I appreciated her honesty and perspective and found her suggestions very enlightening. Her first comment was that “both her and her husband are college educated and she has a teaching degree” and yet she didn’t truly know what the test scores meant and what should she be doing now for her child. Sound familiar? I loved it when she wrote, “I didn’t know what I didn’t know.” Some of her other suggestions included an initial conference to explain the results of the testing, a book list of recommended reading and a mentor-like seasoned gifted parent for exchanging parenting stories. These are all things that I can implement easily next school year.

My encounter with the mom at the repair shop in a way parallels my experience as an educator of gifted children. I understand that those who know how cars work are better equipped to service and maintain them. They give me advice on how to make my car function at its best. Likewise, parents of gifted children would greatly benefit from understanding the identification process and how to support their gifted children throughout their school years. As ‘mechanics’ of a sort, gifted educators are a vital part of equipping the parents of identified gifted children to service and maintain their little gifted engines so they obtain peak performance in the classroom and throughout their educational careers.


 
Guest Blogger - Reprinted with permission of Stacia Taylor at http://ameanderingjourney.wordpress.com/

I often find myself listening to conversations about talent development for
gifted children. Now, I actually believe altruistic talent development is a
great thing for kids: take their areas of strength and help them grow. What’s
not to love, right? As with any altruistic notion, implementation and the need
to pay for said altruism often takes away from the vision. What troubles me most
is a sense of entitlement society seems to feel toward a child’s brilliance and
how this entitlement infects the idea of talent development and twists it. I
don’t mean holding high expectations of meeting your potential. I have high
expectations for my girls but I don’t have expectations of what meeting their
potential looks like or how they will “owe me” for supporting and helping them
develop. I mean the notion that society feels ownership toward an individual’s
intellectual gifts. For instance, it makes me pretty crazed when people tell my
eldest daughter, ”Don’t be a philosopher. You are so smart, you should be a
doctor and cure cancer.” As her parent, my first thought is, ”Have you ever seen
her artwork or listened to her music? My goodness, I wish she would quit taking
art off the table of viable career paths.” My second thought runs along the
lines of, ”You don’t own her intellect. Why are you telling her what to do? You
don’t even know her well.” This is followed closely with the thought, ”She has
never been on the path to be a doctor and has shown no interest in medical
research. Is she smart enough to pass the courses? Sure. Does she have the
passion for medicine? No.” These “well-meaning” adults don’t realize the
damaging message they have just given her: “What you want to do is meaningless. You owe us a cure for cancer because you are wicked smart. Any other path is a waste.” Now, if this had only happened once, I wouldn’t be writing this blog post. It has happened a countless and depressing number of times. This brings me to my worry about the movement toward talent development with gifted children. If I felt like we wanted to develop talent because supporting and encouraging our children is beneficial for society then I would be the first passenger on the ship. That isn’t what the conversation has been, in the United States. The conversation is, ”If we develop the talents of academically gifted children, imagine what they can produce for our society.” It is subtle but the message is, ”In return for developing your talent, you owe us.” Our society has also begun to send a second message, ”Artists and philosophers are not as important to society as scientists and mathematicians.” I beg to differ. There is balance in all things. The great minds of science and mathematics were often also philosophers and artists. We can’t separate out talents like we are separating the wheat from the chaff because art and philosophy are not chaff. They are wheat just like science and mathematics.

Here is my opinion: We should develop talent because it is the best practice
for growing well-rounded children. It is the fertilizer for the seeds. We should
be ecstatic for the wheat we receive but not become angry with the seed if it
didn’t produce enough wheat or maybe wasn’t the variety we thought we wanted. We enjoy the wheat we have and are grateful. The same holds true for talented children. They don’t owe society their gifts and we should be grateful when they share their great gifts with us in whichever form those gifts take. My daughters don’t owe society another *Sputnik moment. Society owes my daughters the support needed for their growth with no expectation of what that result will be. When support is freely given, people feel more inclined to give back. When support is given with demands, people feel protective of their gifts.

Think about it. Won’t our society be better for creating happy, supported
children over creating the next Sputnik moment?

 *This post is somewhat in response to Paula Olszewski-Kubilius’ opinion piece
in The Hill on May 13, 2012 but it is mostly an aggregate of things I have
pondered over the years. The article can be found here:
http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/education/225289-stop-short-changing-our-most-gifted-children

 
At the start of next year, teachers will be given individual value added scores for your child. These scores are intended to help teachers figure out where your child is starting out at and where they should end up at academically. Teachers will use this data along with standards and assessments to set learning targets for the coming year. To request your student's individual value added score contact your district's point person.

Acadia   Ellan Kay Baggett   [email protected]
Allen   Diane Marcantel   [email protected]
Ascension   Gwen Price   [email protected]
Assumption   Tootie Hock   [email protected]
Avoyelles   Thelma Prater   [email protected]
Baker   David Grisby   [email protected]
Beauregard   James Herrington   [email protected]
Bienville   Bill L. Davis, Jr.   [email protected]
Bogalusa   April Nobles   [email protected]
Bossier Janiene Batchelor   [email protected]
Caddo   Charles Lowder   [email protected]
Calcasieu   Johna Rion   [email protected]
Caldwell   Robin Nelson   [email protected]
Cameron   Robert Kimball   [email protected]
Catahoula   Gwile Paul Freeman   [email protected]
Central Community School System   Gavin Vitter[email protected]
Claiborne   Dr. Janice Williams   [email protected]
Concordia    Ann Sandidge   [email protected]
Desoto  Noel   [email protected]
East Baton Rouge   Beanka Brumfield-Williams   [email protected]
East Carroll   Jo Ann Thompson   [email protected]
East Feliciana    Knight Roddy   [email protected]
Evangeline   Michael Lombas   [email protected]
Franklin   Lanny Johnson   [email protected]
Grant   Paula Crawford; Becky Reeder   [email protected], [email protected]
Iberia   Suzanne Whitaker   [email protected]
Iberville   Brandie Blanchard   [email protected]
Jackson (Option 1)   Sam Strozier   [email protected]
Jefferson   Katie Coburn   [email protected]
Jefferson Davis Brian M. LeJeune   [email protected]
Lafayette   Karen Williams   [email protected]
Lafourche   Bernita Deville   [email protected]
LaSalle Parish   Tish Budemer   [email protected]
Lincoln   Paula Pardue   [email protected]
Livingston   Dawn Rush   [email protected]
Madison   Clara Durr   [email protected]
Monroe   Teresa Foreman   [email protected]
Morehouse   Prince Ella Williams   [email protected]
Natchitoches Parish   Linda Page   [email protected]
Orleans   Dominique Wilson   [email protected]
Ouachita   Don Coker   [email protected]
Plaquemines   Alberta Cousson   [email protected]
Pointe Coupee   Lisa D'Aquil   a[email protected]
Rapides   Emily Weatherford   [email protected]
Red River Parish   Alison N Hughes   [email protected]
Richland   Harold Gallman   [email protected]
Lee[email protected]
St. Bernard   Charles Raviotta   [email protected]g
St. Charles   Frederick Treuting   [email protected]
St. Helena Parish   Sonia Fields-Guiterrez   [email protected]
St. James   Carol Webre   [email protected]
St. John the Baptist   Dr. Leigh Ann Beard   [email protected]
St. Landry   Matthew Scruggin   s[email protected]
St. Martin   Kellie H. LeBlanc   [email protected]
St. Mary   Ricky Armelin   [email protected]
St. Tammany Teacher's local leader 
Tangipahoa   Ron Genco   [email protected]
Tensas   Bobby Blount   [email protected]
Terrebonne    Carol Davis   [email protected]
Union   Cynthia Gatson   [email protected]
Vermilion   Mr. Jerome Puyau[email protected]
Vernon Parish   Mike Kay[email protected]
Washington   Trisha Smith[email protected]
Webster   Charlotte Dean   [email protected]
West Baton Rouge    Annette Mire   [email protected]
West Carroll Parish   Mark Bowman   [email protected]
West Feliciana   Steven Comfort   [email protected]
Winn Parish   Al Simmons   [email protected]
Zachary Community Schools   Yolanda Williams   [email protected]